HeritageDaily – Archaeology News

  • Home
  • Past Sciences
    • Anthropology
    • Archaeology
    • Heritage
    • Palaeontology
    • Palaeoanthropology
  • GeoSciences
    • Climate Change
    • Geology
    • Natural History
    • Space & Planetary
  • General
    • Biology
    • Chemistry
    • Conflict
    • Physics
    • Politics
    • Tech & Engineering
  • Travel
  • Interesting
    • Maps
    • Education
    • Heritage Lists
    • Apps
  • About
    • About Us
    • Regular Contributors
    • Contact Us
    • Newsletter Subscription
    • Advertise
    • Editorial Guidelines
  • Apps
  • Shop
HeritageDaily – Archaeology News

Campaigners dumbfounded by double standards over Shropshire hillfort sites

by HeritageDailySeptember 24, 2015September 26, 2016328
 

A campaign group has accused authorities of staggering double standards over development affecting Shropshire’s historic landscape.

The backlash comes as Shropshire Council’s conservation department and Historic England rally to object to development skirting Caer Caradoc hillfort near Church Stretton in the south of the County.

Meanwhile, the two bodies have signed an outline agreement in Shropshire’s SAMDev local plan for 117 houses across the landscape of Old Oswestry hillfort in the north, despite fresh acknowledgement from leading academics of its national importance.

Shropshire Council conservation officer, Berwyn Murray, has argued that an application for 85 homes at Caer Caradoc will impact the hillfort and valley as well as a nearby grade II listed 18th century farmhouse. He cites concerns that the proposed development will “urbanise the currently open and agricultural wider setting.” John Yates, an inspector for Historic England, has also objected, saying that the hillfort would be “closer to the suburbs, and less rural” if the housing goes ahead.

Maggie Rowlands of campaign group, HOOOH (Hands Off Old Oswestry Hillfort), said: “We are encouraged that strong objections are being made in defence of these wonderful historic assets and rural landscape in Church Stretton. But the same arguments can and should be applied in the case of Old Oswestry given its widely-accepted national if not international significance.”

Nevertheless, Shropshire Council is refusing to acknowledge that Old Oswestry’s historic farmland setting faces similar degradation from development sweeping ever closer to the monument. It has stated it “does not accept that proposed development (OSW004) would result in substantial harm to the significance of the hillfort.” And it claims that “the sensitivity of the Old Oswestry hillfort and its setting have been recognised by Shropshire Council throughout the local plan-making process.”

HOOOH points out that the Council’s opinion has not been supported by any evidence and is in stark contrast to the assessment by a group of 12 eminent British archaeologists that housing would cause “irreparable harm to the hillfort’s setting”. They include Professor Sir Barry Cunliffe and Professor Lord Renfrew of Kaimsthorn, while RESCUE (British Archaeological Trust), the Council for British Archaeology and The Prehistoric Society have all made similar objections. Testifying to the hillfort’s significance, representatives among them have described it as the “Stonehenge of the Iron Age” and in the “Premier League of British archaeological sites”.

   

“We ask why so little support to protect this significant hinterland landscape has come from Shropshire’s historic environment team,” said Mrs Rowlands. “It appears that OSW004 is being forced on us by the political will of the Council to fulfil their housing quota in SAMDev at any cost.”

Tim Malim, heritage planning adviser to HOOOH, said: “There is an inexplicable lack of appreciation for one of Shropshire’s and the UK’s most important heritage assets. There is also a serious lack of understanding for planning policy and the heritage significance of the hillfort’s setting in believing that development at OSW004 is sound. The LPA is leaving itself wide open to legal challenges while there is such glaring inconsistency in the interpretation of planning guidance in relation to the County’s heritage.”

Campaigners are also extremely disappointed with Historic England’s capitulation over OSW004. Having objected during the early stages of SAMDev, the national body has since agreed principles for housing, subject to design approval, in a statement of common ground. This is despite its stated concerns over the loss of the hillfort’s rural setting to urban development and the disruption of views to and from the hillfort that contribute to the aesthetic value.

HOOOH says that Historic England’s contradictory approach is further highlighted by its objection to the allocation of land in SAMDev to extend an industrial park adjacent to Shrewsbury’s historic Battlefield. The heritage body is concerned about the impact of development on key views to and from the site, and potential harm to the registered battlefield’s wider designation. This is a directly parallel situation with OSW004 at Old Oswestry, say campaigners.

Mr Malim added: “We have submitted evidence to the LPA showing that there would be substantial impacts on the heritage significance of Old Oswestry from the urban encroachment of 117 houses. These include assessments using industry standard methods and Historic England’s own criteria on the setting of heritage assets.”

However, HOOOH says it is encouraged that rulings elsewhere are providing some clarity on the interpretation of harm to heritage setting under national planning guidelines (NPPF).

In 2013, the Court of Appeal overturned plans for four wind turbines on land at the 17th century Barnwell Manor near Lyveden New Bield in Northamptonshire. The judge ruled there had been a failure by a public inquiry inspector “properly to interpret and apply the relevant planning policies on the effect of development on the setting of heritage sites, which meant that the balancing exercise was flawed”.

The ruling has had notable repercussions for planning applications affecting heritage sites.

Andrew Batterton, legal director for global law firm, DLA Piper LLP, wrote in The Planner magazine earlier this year: “Even less than substantial harm impacts that fail to preserve setting and that contribute to significance of a heritage asset are now expected to be afforded considerable weight, creating a strong presumption against the grant of planning permission.”

HOOOH says if proper weight is given to Old Oswestry’s significance, the scale of harm from development in its setting, and to its community value as a heritage asset, then any unbiased balancing exercise regarding harm versus the need for housing must clearly rule OSW004 as unsound.

The SAMDev plan has been undergoing examination by Inspector Claire Sherratt for over a year. She is expected to submit her final plan to Shropshire Council in the next few weeks.

More on the Old Oswestry campaign here:

@OldOswestryFort                        

https://www.facebook.com/OldOswestryHillfort

http://oldoswestryhillfort.co.uk/

Download the HeritageDaily mobile application on iOS and Android

 

Planet Knowledge is a FREE to watch video on demand channel available on Freeview HD (Channel 265), Youview, Samsung connected TV’s, selected smart tv’s, tablets and smartphones using Android or iOS.

 
Breaking Ground HeritageHeritageheritage newsheritage press releasesShare0
HeritageDaily
HeritageDaily is an independent online magazine for archaeological and associated disciplines, dedicated to the heritage and historical sector. We identified the need for a central resource offering the latest archaeological news, journals, articles and press releases.

Related posts

How the Aztecs could improve modern urban farming

HeritageDailyNovember 4, 2019

Richard III and the Battle of Bosworth – By Mike Ingram

HeritageDailyNovember 1, 2019November 1, 2019

Day of the Dead: From Aztec goddess worship to modern Mexican celebration

HeritageDailyOctober 29, 2019

Science reveals improvements in Roman building techniques

HeritageDailyOctober 25, 2019

New study suggests the original location of the Bayeux Tapestry is finally solved

HeritageDailyOctober 25, 2019

Feathers may have been used more than 300,000 years ago in the Levant

HeritageDailySeptember 25, 2019September 25, 2019

Common carp aquaculture in Neolithic China dating back 8,000 years

HeritageDailySeptember 16, 2019

Uncovered London – Discovering the hidden history of London

HeritageDailyAugust 30, 2019September 13, 2019

The road to Scandinavia’s bronze age: Trade routes, metal provenance, and mixing

HeritageDailyJuly 24, 2019

The Real Assassin’s Creed

HeritageDailyJuly 24, 2019July 31, 2019

Alan Turing to be the face of UK £50 note

HeritageDailyJuly 15, 2019July 15, 2019

Retracing ancient routes to Australia

HeritageDailyJune 20, 2019

Trending Posts

Roman Sex, Sexuality, Slaves and Lex Scantinia

HeritageDailyJanuary 9, 2018April 11, 2019
January 9, 2018April 11, 20196

Was Cleopatra beautiful? The archaeological evidence

Robyn AntanovskiiAugust 4, 2015April 9, 2019
August 4, 2015April 9, 201915

Archaeologists discover bread that predates agriculture by 4,000 years

HeritageDailyJuly 16, 2018July 18, 2018
July 16, 2018July 18, 20180

Half the population of the Viking-town Sigtuna were migrants

HeritageDailyAugust 23, 2018
August 23, 20180

Georadar detects a Viking ship in Norway

HeritageDailyOctober 15, 2018October 15, 2018
October 15, 2018October 15, 20180

ARCHAEOLOGY NEWS

Long-distance timber trade underpinned the Roman Empire’s construction

HeritageDailyDecember 5, 2019
December 5, 2019
The ancient Romans relied on long-distance timber trading to construct their empire, according to a...

The art of the Roman surveyors emerges from newly discovered pavements in...

HeritageDailyDecember 4, 2019

Ostrich eggshell beads reveal 10,000 years of cultural interaction across Africa

HeritageDailyNovember 28, 2019

ANTHROPOLOGY NEWS

Otago scientist excavates medieval Uzbek cemetery

HeritageDailyNovember 26, 2019November 26, 2019
November 26, 2019November 26, 2019
An Otago scientist has been digging up human remains in the backyards of Uzbek villagers...

Scientists explore Egyptian mummy bones with x-rays and infrared light

HeritageDailyNovember 12, 2019

Study reveals that humans migrated from Europe to the Levant 40,000 years...

HeritageDailyNovember 6, 2019

PALAEOANTHROPOLOGY NEWS

Inbreeding and population/demographic shifts could have led to Neanderthal extinction

HeritageDailyNovember 28, 2019
November 28, 2019
Small populations, inbreeding, and random demographic fluctuations could have been enough to cause Neanderthal extinction,...

Human migration out of Africa may have followed monsoons in the Middle...

HeritageDailyNovember 26, 2019

Were other humans the first victims of the sixth mass extinction?

HeritageDailyNovember 22, 2019

LATEST NEWS

Hidden giant planet revealed around tiny white dwarf star

HeritageDailyDecember 5, 2019
by HeritageDailyDecember 5, 20190

Long-distance timber trade underpinned the Roman Empire’s construction

HeritageDailyDecember 5, 2019
by HeritageDailyDecember 5, 20190

The art of the Roman surveyors emerges from newly discovered pavements in...

HeritageDailyDecember 4, 2019
by HeritageDailyDecember 4, 20190

Justinianic plague not a landmark pandemic?

HeritageDailyDecember 4, 2019
by HeritageDailyDecember 4, 20190

Inbreeding and population/demographic shifts could have led to Neanderthal extinction

HeritageDailyNovember 28, 2019
by HeritageDailyNovember 28, 20190

Ostrich eggshell beads reveal 10,000 years of cultural interaction across Africa

HeritageDailyNovember 28, 2019
by HeritageDailyNovember 28, 20190

Barbequed clams on the menu for ancient Puerto Ricans

HeritageDailyNovember 28, 2019
by HeritageDailyNovember 28, 20190

Researchers say animal-like embryos preceded animal appearance

HeritageDailyNovember 28, 2019
by HeritageDailyNovember 28, 20190

Imaging uncovers secrets of medicine’s mysterious ivory manikins

HeritageDailyNovember 27, 2019
by HeritageDailyNovember 27, 20190

Human migration out of Africa may have followed monsoons in the Middle...

HeritageDailyNovember 26, 2019
by HeritageDailyNovember 26, 20190

Soldieron! delivers innovative and exciting projects that build community cohesion, and assist the personal development of vulnerable, disadvantaged or socially-isolated people.  

Find out more

HeritageDaily Shop

logo
Follow us
FacebookTwitterInstagram
@2019 - www.heritagedaily.com. All Right Reserved.
  • About Us
  • Shop & Merchandise
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Cookies Policy
HeritageDaily – Archaeology News
FacebookTwitterInstagram
  • Home
  • Past Sciences
    • Anthropology
    • Archaeology
    • Heritage
    • Palaeontology
    • Palaeoanthropology
  • GeoSciences
    • Climate Change
    • Geology
    • Natural History
    • Space & Planetary
  • General
    • Biology
    • Chemistry
    • Conflict
    • Physics
    • Politics
    • Tech & Engineering
  • Travel
  • Interesting
    • Maps
    • Education
    • Heritage Lists
    • Apps
  • About
    • About Us
    • Regular Contributors
    • Contact Us
    • Newsletter Subscription
    • Advertise
    • Editorial Guidelines
  • Apps
  • Shop