How changing body shape affected balance and posture during the evolution of dinosaurs
Credit : Royal Veterinary College
Research published on 24 April 2013 from The Royal Veterinary College, in the journal Nature, uses realistic three-dimensional computer models of the skeletons and bodies of dinosaurs and their relatives to show how body shape changed during dinosaur evolution and its consequences for the way dinosaurs, and eventually birds, stood and moved.
The study reveals for the first time that, contrary to popular opinion, it was the enlargement of the forelimbs over time, rather than the shortening and lightening of the tail, that led to bipedal (two-legged) dinosaurs gradually adopting an unusually crouched posture, with the thigh (femur) held nearly horizontally – a trait inherited by their descendants: birds (see Figure 1 below).
The research group used scanning or digitising technology to create 3D images of the skeletons of 17 archosaurs (land animals including living crocodiles and birds as well as extinct dinosaurs), then digitally added “flesh” around the skeletons to estimate the overall shape of the body as well as the individual body segments such as the head, forelimbs and tail.
The research was led by Dr. Vivian Allen and Professor John R. Hutchinson of The Royal Veterinary College’s Structure & Motion Lab, stemming from Dr. Allen’s PhD work with Prof. Hutchinson. Allen and Hutchinson invited colleagues Dr. Karl Bates (University of Liverpool) and Zhiheng Li (at the time, at the Institute for Vertebrate Paleontology and Paleoanthropology in Beijing, China) to join their team.
Dr. Allen says, “We basically started from a simple digital ‘shrink-wrap’ of the whole skeleton. From this, we expanded the ‘shrink-wrap’ to match how we much flesh we think existed around the different parts of the skeleton. This was based on both detailed reconstruction of the muscular anatomy of each animal, and on what we have measured from CT scans of their living relatives. ‘Accuracy’ can be a misleading term in reconstructing extinct animals, but this approach gave us a repeatable and scientifically-sound estimate for the size and shape of these animals as they were in life, not just as skeletons.”
Prior research had shown that the first archosaurs, around 245 million years ago, were superficially like modern crocodiles – four-legged animals with long, heavy tails, although with longer limbs for living and moving on land. However, early in the evolution of the dinosaur lineage, about 235 million years ago, dinosaurs became bipedal, a trait inherited by their descendants: birds. Birds stand and walk in an unusually crouched posture, with the thigh (femur) held nearly horizontally (see Figure 1c); unlike the more vertical limbs in humans, for example.
Palaeontologists had agreed for years that this strange way of moving evolved gradually as the tail became shorter, shifting the centre of mass of certain dinosaurs progressively forward as those dinosaurs became more “bird-like”, and thereby requiring the legs to become less vertical and more crouched to keep the centre of mass balanced over the feet (see Figure 1).
Figure 1: Animal standing or at the midpoint of a step (a). For the animal to balance, forces applied by the feet (red) must match the force of body weight (blue) pointing downwards from the centre of mass (yellow/black). If the centre of mass moves forward (b), then the feet must move forward (and thus the limb must get more crouched) to maintain balance, as in (c).
Prof. Hutchinson says, “Our results surprised even us: it wasn’t primarily the shortening and lightening of the tail that drove the change in dinosaur centre of mass and thus posture, but rather the enlargement of the forelimbs. Birds (flying dinosaurs) obviously have large forelimbs for flight. But dinosaurs close to the origin of birds enlarged their forelimbs for reasons other than powered flight, such as prey capture or negotiating complex terrain. These enlarged forelimbs became noticeable in animals such as the famed feathered dinosaurs Microraptor and Velociraptor, as well as the earliest bird, Archaeopteryx.
“We’d never doubted the hypothesis that the tail was responsible for the major changes in dinosaur balance and posture. The tail is the most obvious change if you look at dinosaur bodies. But as we analyzed, and re-analysed, and punishingly scrutinised our data, we gradually realized that everyone had forgotten to check what influence the forelimbs had on balance and posture, and that this influence was greater than that of the tail or other parts of the body.”
Allen adds, “We had set out to simply use modern, computer-aided techniques to illustrate how and when the centre of mass changed its position in dinosaurs, because the timing of that change had been controversial: either gradual, or more sudden and associated with the first birds and the origin of flight. We found some support for both scenarios: there were gradual changes early on in dinosaurs, but we were amazed by how much the increase in forelimb size began altering the centre of mass just before when flight may have first evolved, in early birds and their closest relatives.”
A major, unexpected implication of the team’s discovery is that, due to the effects on centre of mass position on leg posture, forelimb size and leg function are biomechanically linked. So, these changes in the forelimb anatomy of dinosaurs, both before and after flight, also altered the way they stood, walked and ran.
Bates adds, “The evolution of birds from their dinosaurian ancestors is historically important not only to dinosaur research but also to the development of the theory of evolution itself. Way back in the 1860’s, Thomas Huxley used Mesozoic dinosaurs and modern birds as key evidence in promoting Darwin’s theory of evolution. In this study, modern digital technologies have allowed us to quantify the ‘descent with modification’ observed by Huxley all those years ago. This quantifiable evidence, derived from fossils, helps make evolution more apparent to a general audience, and helps demonstrate exactly how scientists understand what they do about evolution.”
Hutchinson concludes, “What was great about this project for us is that we were able to reconstruct the evolution of whole body dimensions in extinct animals in a quantitative way for the first time, and yet that way was honest about how much we don’t know about those dimensions. However, all that uncertainty ended up not mattering so much- there were clear patterns in changes in dinosaur body dimensions even when considering all the unknown factors. I really like the challenge of tackling such problems in science. It’s gratifying when you feel you’ve done your best to be very cautious and a cool discovery emerges from the hard work everyone put in. And anyone can join in the fun– we’ve shared all the major methods and 3D images from our study so others can use them for any purpose. It’s a win for dinosaur fans and scientists.”
The study was partly supported by funds from the Natural Environment Research Council and the Royal Society.
See Evolution of Dinosaur Body Shape and Locomotion for more information.
Contributing Source : Royal Veterinary College
HeritageDaily : Archaeology News : Archaeology Press Releases